“Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted. The trouble is, I don’t know which half.”
That quote from department store pioneer John Wanamaker is over 100 years old, but many Houston business owners still feel the same frustration today. You’re spending money on marketing—but is it actually working?
The good news: unlike Wanamaker, you have tools to measure exactly what’s working. Here’s how to track your marketing ROI without getting lost in spreadsheets.
Why Measuring Marketing ROI Matters
When you don’t measure, you guess. And guessing leads to:
- Wasting money on marketing that doesn’t work
- Cutting effective marketing because you don’t realize it’s working
- Making decisions based on feelings instead of facts
- Inability to scale what’s successful
Measuring ROI lets you spend every marketing dollar with purpose.
The Basic ROI Formula
Marketing ROI isn’t complicated:
ROI = (Revenue from Marketing - Marketing Cost) / Marketing Cost × 100
If you spent $1,000 on Google Ads and those ads generated $5,000 in sales:
($5,000 - $1,000) / $1,000 × 100 = 400% ROI
That $1,000 investment returned $4,000 in profit (before other costs). Simple enough in theory.
The challenge is tracking which revenue came from which marketing activity.
Setting Up Basic Tracking
Before you can measure ROI, you need systems to track where customers come from.
Ask Every Customer
The simplest method: ask “How did you hear about us?” at the point of sale or during intake. Train your staff to ask consistently and record the answers.
This isn’t perfect—people forget or attribute their decision to the last touchpoint rather than what actually influenced them—but it provides useful directional data.
Use Unique Tracking Methods
Make each marketing channel identifiable:
Unique phone numbers: Services like CallRail give you different phone numbers for your website, Google Ads, and print ads. You’ll know exactly which channel generated each call.
Unique URLs: Create specific landing pages or URLs for different campaigns. Your direct mail piece sends people to yoursite.com/spring, while your Facebook ad sends them to yoursite.com/fb.
Coupon codes: Different codes for different channels. “GOOGLE15” vs “MAIL15” tells you where buyers came from.
UTM parameters: These are tags added to URLs that show up in Google Analytics. They tell you exactly which campaign, source, and ad drove each website visitor.
Set Up Google Analytics
If you’re not using Google Analytics on your website, start today. It’s free and shows you:
- Where your website visitors come from
- Which pages they view
- How long they stay
- Whether they complete goals (form submissions, purchases, etc.)
Set up “goals” to track the actions that matter: contact form submissions, phone clicks, downloads, purchases.
Tracking Different Marketing Channels
Each channel requires slightly different measurement approaches.
SEO (Search Engine Optimization)
SEO brings organic search traffic—people who find you through Google without clicking ads.
Track these metrics:
- Organic search traffic (Google Analytics → Acquisition → Organic Search)
- Keyword rankings for important terms
- Conversions from organic visitors
- Revenue from organic leads
Calculate ROI: If you spend $2,000/month on SEO and it generates $10,000 in new business monthly, your ROI is 400%.
Challenge: SEO results compound over time. Month one might show negative ROI while month six shows strong returns. Evaluate over at least 6-12 months.
Paid Advertising (Google Ads, Facebook Ads)
Digital advertising provides the clearest tracking because platforms record exactly which clicks led to conversions.
Track these metrics:
- Cost per click
- Conversion rate
- Cost per lead/sale
- Total revenue generated
Calculate ROI: Google Ads shows you spend vs. conversions directly. Connect it to your CRM to track which leads became customers and what they spent.
Challenge: Some customers need multiple touches before buying. First-click vs. last-click attribution can tell different stories.
Social Media Marketing
Organic social media is harder to measure because it influences decisions indirectly.
Track these metrics:
- Website traffic from social media
- Engagement rates (meaningful comments, shares)
- Direct messages that lead to sales
- Conversions from social referrals
Calculate ROI: Account for your time or your team’s time creating content. If you spend 10 hours monthly on social media and your time is worth $50/hour, that’s $500 in cost before any ad spend.
Challenge: Social media builds brand awareness over time. Its full value doesn’t show up in immediate conversions.
Email Marketing
Email typically shows the clearest ROI because you’re reaching people who already know you.
Track these metrics:
- Open rates and click rates
- Revenue per email sent
- Revenue per subscriber
- List growth rate
Calculate ROI: Your email platform’s cost plus time creating emails vs. direct sales from email campaigns.
Challenge: Email nurtures leads who may eventually buy through other channels. Direct attribution understates email’s contribution.
Local/Traditional Marketing
Print ads, direct mail, sponsorships, and networking are harder to track but not impossible.
Tracking methods:
- Unique phone numbers
- Specific coupon codes
- “How did you hear about us?” tracking
- Increases in branded search volume after campaigns
Understanding Attribution
Here’s where measurement gets complicated: customers rarely come from a single source.
Someone might:
- See your Facebook ad
- Search your company name on Google
- Read some of your blog posts
- Get your email newsletter
- Finally call to schedule an appointment
Which channel gets credit for the sale?
Attribution Models
Last-touch attribution: The final touchpoint before conversion gets all credit. Simple but undervalues awareness-building activities.
First-touch attribution: The first touchpoint gets credit. Values awareness but ignores nurturing.
Linear attribution: Every touchpoint gets equal credit. More balanced but requires sophisticated tracking.
For most small businesses: Use last-touch as your primary measurement but recognize that other channels contribute. If you stop social media and leads drop even though people technically converted from search, social was doing work.
Setting Realistic Expectations
Different marketing channels have different ROI profiles:
Quick ROI (1-3 months):
- Google Ads for commercial-intent keywords
- Email marketing to existing list
- Referral programs
Medium-term ROI (3-6 months):
- Local SEO improvements
- Social media advertising
- Content marketing to engaged audiences
Long-term ROI (6-12+ months):
- Comprehensive SEO strategy
- Brand building
- Organic social media
- Networking and relationship building
Don’t expect SEO to perform like paid ads in month one. Judge each channel on its appropriate timeframe.
Creating a Simple Measurement System
You don’t need expensive software to track ROI. Start with:
A Monthly Marketing Spreadsheet
Track for each channel:
- Amount spent (including your time at an hourly rate)
- Leads generated
- Customers acquired
- Revenue from those customers
Over time, you’ll see which channels consistently deliver and which underperform.
Regular Review Rhythm
Weekly: Check high-level metrics (website traffic, ad spend, leads)
Monthly: Calculate ROI by channel, compare to previous months, look for trends
Quarterly: Evaluate strategy and reallocate budget based on performance
What to Do With Your Data
Numbers are useless if you don’t act on them.
When something works: Invest more. If Google Ads produces 5x ROI, increase your budget there before trying new channels.
When something doesn’t work: Diagnose first, then decide. Is the channel wrong for your business, or is your execution the problem? Sometimes better ads or landing pages fix underperforming campaigns.
When you’re unsure: Run tests. Increase spend for one month and see if results scale proportionally.
Common Measurement Mistakes
Measuring too soon. Give campaigns enough time to work. Judging SEO after one month or Facebook ads after three days leads to bad decisions.
Ignoring lifetime value. A customer who costs $200 to acquire but spends $3,000 over three years is highly profitable. Don’t just measure first purchase.
Over-valuing easy metrics. Likes, impressions, and followers feel good but don’t pay bills. Focus on leads, customers, and revenue.
Not accounting for your time. “Free” organic marketing costs your hours. Include that when calculating ROI.
Start Measuring This Week
Pick your highest-spend marketing channel. Set up basic tracking for it—even if just asking customers how they found you. Calculate ROI at the end of the month.
Once you’re comfortable with one channel, expand to others. Within a few months, you’ll have clear data on what’s working.
Need Help Making Sense of Your Marketing?
Understanding which digital marketing efforts actually drive results is crucial for smart budget allocation. We help Houston businesses track what matters and invest in what works.
Want to know if your marketing is actually paying off? Contact us for a clear-eyed look at your numbers.
Topics
Need help with your website or marketing?
We help Houston businesses grow with websites that work and marketing that delivers results.
Let's Talk